2022 Angelica Garnett Undergraduate Essay Prize Results

Each year, the IVWS runs the annual Angelica Garnett Undergraduate Essay Prize contest. The winner traditionally wins a cash prize and publication in a future issue of Virginia Woolf Miscellany. This year, the field was incredibly competitive. The judges recommended a winner, but the second and third place essays were so excellent that they also recommended that both be named runners-up. The IVWS is also planning a Spring 2023 event to celebrate this year’s winners.

Here are the results:

Winner: Eleanor Clark (Merton College, U of Oxford)

Eleanor Clark’s essay is entitled, “Breaking the silence?”: Talking, Speaking and the Dissipation of Meaning in Virginia Woolf’s Novels. Eleanor is a second-year undergraduate reading English at Merton College, Oxford, and was raised in rural Devon in the south-west of England. She has particular interests in twentieth-century women’s writing, the novel, and literatures of place and landscape.

Her winning essay contends that Woolf establishes a distinction between talk and speech. Talking imparts language and is heard, whereas speaking imparts meaning and is listened to. In talk, meaning dissipates, weakening communication to produce the familiar alienated modernist subject. Unlike T.S. Eliot and Jospeh Conrad, who are preoccupied with this (usually male) figure, Woolf’s characters evade the dissipation of meaning because they speak. This distinction stands against simplistic developmental readings of Woolf: she may move formally from external dialogue to internal monologue, but The Voyage Out and Night and Day are speaking to The Waves and Between the Acts.

Runners Up: Saskia May (U of Sussex) and Jasmine Woodcock (Huddersfield U)

Saskia May’s essay is entitled, Abandoned, Domestic Objects ‘continuing without us’ in Ecological Landscapes in Virginia Woolf’s “Solid Objects. Saskia completed her undergraduate studies in English literature at the University of Sussex and is currently studying her Masters in English literature at University College London. She is the winner of the 2021 Doris Lessing Essay Prize for her essay titled  “Maternal Ambivalence in Doris Lessing’s Letters,” an archival research project using Lessing’s letters to her friend, Leonard Smith (“Smithie”) archived at the Keep, University of Sussex. Saskia is presenting at the 2023 MLA Convention  and is delivering a paper on “Working Motherhood – Maternal Ambivalence and Writing Conditions in Doris Lessing’s Letters.” Saskia has particular interests in motherhood,  forms of life writing,  the intersections of class and race in Post-war Britain, and eco-critical literature

Saskia’s essay explores Woolf’s consideration of  abandoned, domestic objects decaying in ecological landscapes in her short story “Solid Objects” (1920).  Saskia is interested in how Woolf depicts objects aside from their anthropocentric use and history, and her essay contends that objects, especially in the context of the current climate crisis,  must be conceived of from a biocentric as opposed to an anthropocentric perspective, for their permanence affects all life on earth.

Jasmine Woodcock’s essay is entitled, Predicting the Present: Orlando is Trans*. Jasmine is currently studying for a Master’s in English Literature at the University of Huddersfield. Her prize submission is an adaptation of my undergraduate dissertation.

“Predicting the Present” points to gender fluid identities as a newly-mainstream understanding. It reads Orlando as a trans*—that is, in essence, non-binary—character, and Orlando as advocating for expression of gender fluidity through the use of the ‘they’ pronoun. The essay argues that Woolf’s Orlando is a presentist text in that its dialogue with gender has resounded to several conceptions of gender throughout its critical history, and continues to engage with changing notions of gender. As well as this, presentist theory acknowledges that modern readers approach a text with modern understandings — in this case, of gender — influencing their readings.

Published by International Virginia Woolf Society

The International Virginia Woolf Society is devoted to encouraging and facilitating the scholarly study of, critical attention to, and general interest in, the work and career of Virginia Woolf, and to facilitate ways in which all people interested in her writings— scholars, critics, teachers, students, artists and general readers—may learn from one another, meet together, contact each other, and help one another. Find out more about our organization, activities, and Virginia Woolf herself by following the links on our home page.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: